Skip to main content

Why Rent Incentives Are a Bad Strategy for Central Florida Single-Family Rentals

Why Rent Incentives Are a Bad Strategy for Central Florida Single-Family Rentals
By Ackley Florida Property Management Monday, February 10, 2025

Landlords of single-family rentals (SFRs) in Central Florida may be tempted to offer rent incentives (like a free month’s rent or move-in discounts) to attract tenants, especially as the market shows signs of cooling. However, data and expert insights suggest this strategy can backfire for SFR owners. Below, we explore Central Florida’s rental market trends, how SFR tenant behavior differs from multifamily (MF) renters, and why gimmicks like rent concessions often hurt more than help in the long run.


Central Florida Rental Market: High Demand, Cooling Trends

Strong Demand But Rising Vacancies: Central Florida (especially the Orlando area) saw explosive rent growth in 2021-2022, but the market leveled off in 2023-2024. In 2024, rents actually dipped slightly – Florida rents were down about 4.1% year-over-year, with Orlando’s average rent roughly 2% lower than a year prior. This softening is largely due to a wave of new apartment construction. More multifamily units were completed in 2023-2024 than any time since the 1970s, which has pushed up vacancy rates. Orlando’s apartment vacancy hit ~10% in late 2024 – the highest in over a decade. By contrast, overall rental vacancies (including houses) were around 8.9% (Comprehensive Housing Market Analysis for

Orlando-Kissimmee-Sanford, Florida), implying single-family homes remained relatively more occupied than large apartment complexes.


Single-Family vs. Multifamily Rents: Even as rent growth slowed, single-family rentals maintained a pricing edge. Nationwide data show SFR homes renting for about 20% more than apartments on average. In fact, SFR rents rose about 4–5% year-over-year, outpacing the ~2% growth in multifamily rents during 2024. This trend held in Florida as well, thanks to many families preferring the space and privacy of a home. Central Florida’s rapid population growth (nearly +1.8% in 2023, fueled by inbound migration) has kept demand robust for rentals in desirable school districts and suburban neighborhoods. This means a well-priced SFR can usually find a tenant even when apartments are offering deals to fill units.


Concessions on the Rise (But Mostly in Apartments): It’s telling that over one-third of U.S. rental listings in mid-2024 advertised some form of concession (like “X weeks free”). In Orlando, Jacksonville, and Tampa – the Florida markets with the most new apartments – concessions have become common as property managers compete for renters. However, these incentives are predominantly an apartment strategy. Large multifamily operators budget for promotions to boost occupancy during lease-ups or soft markets. Single-family rentals, on the other hand, are typically leased one-by-one by small landlords or investors who can’t spread

the cost of a free month across hundreds of units. As we’ll see, what makes sense for a 300-unit apartment building often makes little sense for an individual home.


SFR Tenants vs. Apartment Tenants: Stability vs. Turnover

Longer Stays and “Home” Mindset: Renters of single-family homes tend to have different priorities and behavior than those in multifamily complexes. SFR tenants are often families, couples planning to have kids, or even older individuals, who treat the rental house as a long-term home. They value extra space, a yard, and access to good schools or a quieter

neighborhood – things not offered by a typical apartment. These renters also stay longer on average. For example, single-person households in SFRs (often independent seniors) stay a minimum of five years on average, given the hassle of moving and their desire for stability (What tenants look for in single-family rentals). Even younger SFR renters (like millennial couples) often intend to stay until they’re ready to buy a home, rather than hop to a new rental in a year. This means turnover in SFRs is generally lower than in apartments.


In contrast, apartment renters – especially in amenity-rich complexes – skew younger and more transient. Many are students or early-career professionals who might move yearly for job changes or simply to chase the next luxury building offering a move-in special. It’s no surprise that tenant retention rates differ widely by market and property type. In some expensive metros, SFR retention rates exceed 85-90% as families rent houses for the long haul (Top Markets for Single-Family Rental Tenant Retention). But in more transient markets, retention can dip into the 70% range. Central Florida falls somewhere in between: it attracts many newcomers (who may rent a house then eventually buy locally or relocate again), but also has a growing base of “renters-by-necessity” who can’t yet afford homeownership and might rent a single-family home for many years.


The key point is that SFR tenants typically seek stability. They pick a house because they want a home, not a temporary stopover. As a landlord, this means your best outcome is to land a responsible renter who will treat your property well and renew their lease year after year.

Keeping that type of tenant happy is far more valuable than squeezing out a slightly higher rent for one year and then losing them. It also means flashy short-term incentives may not be the decisive factor for someone choosing a home – in fact, a seasoned SFR renter might wonder why a nice house even needs a gimmick to attract interest.


The Temptation of Rent Incentives

What Are Rent Incentives? Rent incentives or concessions are perks offered to entice a tenant to sign or renew a lease. Common examples include: a free month of rent, a reduced security deposit, waiving application or pet fees, or offering free services (like lawn care or a gym membership). These sweeteners effectively reduce the tenant’s cost, at least initially. For

instance, “1st month free” is essentially an ~8% annual rent discount spread over a one-year lease.


Why Landlords Offer Them: In a soft market or during periods of high vacancy, landlords use incentives to stand out from the competition. It’s cheaper to give up one month’s rent than to sit vacant for several months with no income. As one Orlando property management company noted, a vacant unit still incurs costs (maintenance, utilities, marketing) without bringing in revenue, so a concession can be worthwhile if it fills the unit faster (What Rent Concessions You Should Consider Offering to New Tenants). Big apartment complexes frequently dangle concessions to keep occupancy up and avoid officially lowering the asking rents (which could impact their market comps or property valuations) (Rent Concessions in Multifamily Properties - ArborCrowd). By advertising a free month on a $2,000 apartment, they effectively get $1,833 per month over the year, but on paper the “rent” is still $2,000 – and later they can try to lease at $2,050 with another concession, rather than openly dropping the base rent.


For individual SFR owners, the calculation is a bit different. If your Orlando rental home isn’t getting applications at $2,000/month, you might consider a concession to avoid prolonged vacancy. The idea of “better to lose one month of rent than have nobody in the home for several months” is valid if demand is truly weak at that price point. Rent incentives can also be used to reward renewals (e.g. a small discount or a bonus for a tenant signing on for another year) as a way to boost retention. In theory, these tactics seem like smart marketing or goodwill gestures.


However, before you rush to post “Free Rent” in your listing, it’s important to understand the downsides – especially in the Central Florida SFR context. Many experts argue that for single-family landlords, concessions are usually the wrong tool. Let’s break down why.


Why Rent Incentives Don’t Work for SFRs in Central Florida

Despite their popularity in the apartment world, rent incentives often prove to be a bad strategy for single-family rentals. Here are several reasons, backed by expert opinions and real-world observations:


  • They Mask the Real Issue – Pricing or Property Mismatch: If your Central Florida rental home is sitting on the market too long, the hard truth is likely that it’s overpriced or not being marketed to the right audience. Throwing in a free month doesn’t truly solve that. As one real estate expert bluntly put it, “chances are you are priced too high, and offering rent concessions… will not help speed up the leasing process.” (Concessions Are Rising, But Private Landlords Should Never Offer Them) Instead of gimmicks, you may need to adjust the rent to market level or improve the property’s condition. In the post-pandemic slowdown, many Orlando landlords learned that listing a home at last year’s  peak  price  would  just  result  in  an  empty  unit  (2025  Florida  Rental  Market  Outlook: Insight From an Orlando Property Manager). It was wiser to drop the asking rent a bit than  to  let  it  linger  vacant  for  months.  In  other  words,  price  it  right,  and  the  tenants  will

come – no discount candy needed.


  • One Free Month Can Attract the Wrong Tenants: A big concern with incentives is who  they attract. Everyone likes a deal, but if a renter’s deciding factor is that free month, they might not be the most stable or qualified applicant. Professional property managers warn that overly generous concessions can expand your applicant pool to unqualified renters – people who may struggle to pay once the normal rent kicks in (Should  I  Offer  Rent  Concessions  at  My  Harford  County  Rental  Property?).  For  example, someone  who  barely  meets  your  income  criteria  might  jump  at  a  “low  move-in  cost”  offer. But after enjoying a discounted first year, they could falter when facing the full rent in year two (or even default early). Essentially, you risk trading a short-term occupancy win for a long-term headache with rent collection.


  • “Concession Chasers” = Higher Turnover: Tenants brought in by a flashy incentive might be predisposed to keep chasing deals. If they moved in for a discount, they may start eyeing the next offer elsewhere as soon as their lease ends. This is common in apartment complexes – renters hop from one building to another to take advantage of move-in specials. You don’t want your single-family home to become part of that circuit. Unfortunately, if you train a tenant to expect concessions, you either have to repeat the incentive at renewal or likely watch them leave. A Maryland property management firm noted that tenants might “expect this incentive to be offered again upon renewal” (Should  I  Offer  Rent  Concessions  at  My  Harford  County  Rental  Property?).  If  you  refuse, those deal-seekers will move out, leading to another vacancy and turnover cost for you. In Central Florida’s SFR market, where you ideally want renters to settle in for multiple years, attracting “incentive shoppers” is counterproductive.


  • Undermining  Lease  Renewals  and  Loyalty:  Even  if  your  incentive  helps  land  a  tenant initially, it can complicate your lease renewal negotiations. Consider a scenario: you gave a tenant 50% off their first month’s rent on a 12-month lease. Effectively, they paid an average of 4% less rent over that year. When renewal time comes, if you propose moving them to the full market rent (with no discount), it might feel like a stealth rent hike to them, even if you’re just ending the concession. The tenant may push back or start looking for other rentals that are offering new move-in deals. You’ve set an expectation that rent is flexible or negotiable. In contrast, landlords who start with a fair market rent and provide good service often find tenants more accepting of standard annual increases (e.g. 3-5%) without needing special perks each time. The goal is to cultivate  a  sense  of  home  and  fairness,  not  a  sense  that  the  tenant  should  always  look for a better bargain. Central Florida property managers stress that retaining a good tenant  by  fostering  goodwill  is  far  better  than  constantly  having  to  lure  new  ones.  As  one Orlando rental expert noted, “A vacancy is a rental owner’s largest expense… Losing a tenant to a huge renewal rate increase or overpricing… is an expense you can avoid by understanding the importance of retaining the tenants in your home.” (2025 Florida Rental Market Outlook: Insight From an Orlando Property Manager) In short, valuing


Your tenant beats enticing a new one.

  • Hit to Long-Term Profitability: Rent incentives come right off your bottom line. Unlike large REIT-owned apartment buildings, most SFR owners can’t amortize that loss elsewhere. Forgoing one month’s rent means you’ve instantly lost ~8% of your annual income on that property. That could be the difference between a profitable year or breaking even – especially considering landlords in Florida face high insurance premiums, property taxes, and maintenance costs on single homes. Moreover, when a tenant attracted by incentives leaves after a year, you incur turnover costs (advertising, cleaning, maybe lost rent during make-ready) all over again. It becomes a vicious cycle that  erodes  your  ROI.  A  seasoned  investor  would  remind  you  that  a  concession  is  not  a one-time loss if it leads to serial turnover – it’s essentially delayed vacancy. You gave up  rent  on  the  front  end  and  you  might  end  up  vacant  on  the  back  end  anyway,  negating the whole purpose. It’s far more cost-effective to secure a tenant who pays slightly less each month but stays multiple years, than one who pays a bit more for 12 months only because of a front-loaded discount. The math of steady occupancy usually wins.


  • Central Florida Case in Point: We only need to look at recent trends to see how SFR incentives can falter. In 2024, as many Orlando apartments advertised “one month free” to fill units in sprawling new complexes, mom-and-pop landlords with single-family homes  generally  did  not  follow suit. Why? Because demand  for  SFRs  remained  solid  – many families were still moving to Central Florida for jobs or remote work, and they preferred renting a house. Those landlords who tried to ask peak rents from 2022 often had to come down on price or risk no takers. A few who experimented with concessions found that it didn’t necessarily translate to better tenants – it just gave away income to folks who would have rented the home anyway if priced $100 cheaper. One industry insider  observed  that  if  a  rental  home  isn’t  leasing  in  a  reasonable  time,  lowering  the  rent slightly will usually do more good than adding a giveaway  (Concessions Are Rising, But Private Landlords Should Never Offer Them). The takeaway: incentives can’t compensate for an out-of-line rent or an average property in a competitive market. Central Florida’s SFR segment is competitive in quality (renters can choose among  many similar suburban homes), but it’s not yet so desperate on price that you need to bribe renters. Owners who focus on making their home a great value – through proper upkeep,  maybe  a  fresh  coat  of  paint,  and  a  fair  rental  rate  –  find  tenants  without  forfeiting a month’s income.


Expert Opinions and Alternatives to Incentives

The consensus among many real estate professionals is that small landlords should be cautious with rent incentives. BiggerPockets, a popular real estate investor forum, reported in 2024 that more property managers were offering short-term perks as rent growth slowed, but cautioned that private landlords “should never offer them” in lieu of correct pricing (Concessions Are Rising, But Private Landlords Should Never Offer ...). The logic is that big operators use

concessions as a calculated marketing expense, whereas an individual landlord often doesn’t benefit in the same way. If an apartment owner gives 50 free rent leases, it’s a hit to their overall revenue but perhaps keeps hundreds of other units at full price. If you with one house give a free month, 100% of your units took a loss.


Professional property managers often advise alternative strategies to boost interest in a rental property without resorting to concessions. For example, instead of $200 off for the first 6 months, invest a similar sum in minor upgrades or curb appeal that make the home more attractive. Sunroom Leasing, an SFR leasing platform, suggests improvements like updating appliances or adding desirable amenities to justify your rent and draw quality tenants. You can also target what SFR renters value: advertise the big backyard, include lawn care in rent, or allow pets (with proper pet fees/deposits) to broaden your tenant pool. These add value without undermining your rent level. Another tip is offering flexible lease terms – in Central Florida’s market, maybe you find a tenant building a house who only needs a 8-10 month lease; accommodating them at a fair rate could fill your vacancy faster than holding out for a 12-month tenant with a discount.


For lease renewals, rather than a blanket concession, consider small loyalty rewards if you fear losing a great tenant. Some landlords give a $100 gift card or a one-time $100 rental credit upon renewal – a modest token of appreciation that doesn’t alter the base rent. This kind of gesture can engender goodwill without creating an expectation of perpetual discounts. It’s a far cry from an entire free month, and it surprises the tenant instead of being something they feel entitled to. Remember, the goal is to keep the tenant thinking of your house as their home. As soon as tenants feel like they constantly have to negotiate or shop around, you’ve lost that intangible commitment that makes them want to stay.


Conclusion: Focus on Value and Retention, Not Gimmicks

Central Florida’s single-family rental market has proven resilient. Even as rents stabilize from prior highs, there is steady demand for well-kept homes at reasonable rents. In this environment, rent incentives are more of a band-aid than a solution – and often an unnecessary cost. Savvy SFR landlords in Orlando, Tampa, and surrounding areas have found success by pricing their rentals right, keeping tenants happy, and minimizing vacancy through good service. As the saying goes, the cheapest rent is the one you don’t lose to vacancy.


Instead of giving away rent to chase occupants, put effort into making your property desirable and your current tenants satisfied. Address maintenance issues promptly, consider upgrades that yield higher rent, and stay attuned to the market so you’re never far above the going rate.

When prospective renters see a fair price for a nice home, they don’t need a promo deal to be interested. And when good tenants feel at home, they’re likely to renew without requiring bribery.


In summary, rent incentives tend to hurt single-family landlords more than help. They can attract the wrong renters, set troublesome expectations, and chip away at your returns. Central Florida’s SFR owners are better off leveraging the intrinsic strengths of this asset class – longer-term tenancies and high rental demand – by focusing on long-term value. As multiple experts noted, if your rental is lingering, revisit your fundamentals rather than reach for freebies

(Concessions Are Rising, But Private Landlords Should Never Offer Them) (2025 Florida Rental Market Outlook: Insight From an Orlando Property Manager). By doing so, you’ll build a more stable and profitable rental investment without the headaches that come with incentive-driven churn.


Sources:

Share

Author

post.authorName
Ackley Florida Property Management
back